Most overrated Stags 11.

[Slackythestag]

Shane Redmond

Maxime Chanot, Alex Jeanin, Michael Raynes, Dan Martin

Craig Dobson, Steven Istead, Andy Burgess, Fraser McClaughan

Niall O'Rafferty
John McCaliskey

Bench:

Neill Collett
Andy Nicholas
Anthony Robinson
Tyrone Thompson
Tomi Ameobi
John Challinor

A special mention to James Alabi who promised "Goals, Goals, Goals" then was sent off on his debut with his first touch and sent back to his parent club.

[Richard Cranium]

George Pilkington

[bobbystagsfan]

George Pilkington

He was terrible for us, I was so buzzing when we'd signed him from luton. What the hell happened? Did he have a bust up with coxy after/during the 4-1 Gateshead defeat and then never played again or something?

[wink68]

Roddy Collins.

[lifestags]

Gary Mills and Jamie Hand we’re meant to be smash the league signings.

[daddycool]

Shane Redmond

Maxime Chanot, Alex Jeanin, Michael Raynes, Dan Martin

Craig Dobson, Steven Istead, Andy Burgess, Fraser McClaughan

Niall O'Rafferty
John McCaliskey

Bench:

Neill Collett
Andy Nicholas
Anthony Robinson
Tyrone Thompson
Tomi Ameobi
John Challinor

A special mention to James Alabi who promised "Goals, Goals, Goals" then was sent off on his debut with his first touch and sent back to his parent club.

Cannot argue with that selection

[PEAR CIDER]

Gary Silk

You’re joking.

No. He was a decent player and deserved many mam of the match accolades but lots of our fans thought he was the non league Cafu. Decent non league full back but not as good as many perceived = over rated..
IMHO

i dont think people thought that imo. He was just a player that loved to get stuck in and gave his all. Technically, he was a bit poor

[Empty FC]

Paul Cannel

Still shout his name when I stub my toe,
or hit my thumb with a hammer.

[Empty FC]

Joe Laidlaw, Alan Waddle.

For us olduns.
This pair were Comedy Gold..

[Empty FC]

Joe Laidlaw, Alan Waddle.

For us olduns.
This pair were Comedy Gold..

On reflection I seem to remember Waddle being a good player.
I think it might be Alan Kennedy who was pants.

[Parkinsons Perm]

Joe Laidlaw, Alan Waddle.

For us olduns.
This pair were Comedy Gold..

On reflection I seem to remember Waddle being a good player.
I think it might be Alan Kennedy who was pants.

Alan Kennedy was that pants he scored the winner in the old European Cup.

Now Keith Kennedy was a different story

[oldweststander]

Some crackers there.

I'l go with Joe Laidlaw, Fraser whatsit and George Pilkington.

[StagsFan83]

Tim Sandercombe in goal.
Def left to right of Jeanin Chanot G Pilkington and Scott Gardner.
Midfield 3 of Gary Mills, James Baxendale and Jamie Hand.

Up front with Craig Dobson one side, Levi Porter the other, and Dominican (I think) international Anthony Robinson just running around cause nobody would pass to him!

[eggy]

Half the players being named in this thread were never rated in the first place, let alone overrated. They were certainly crap though

[lifestags]

Half the players being named in this thread were never rated in the first place, let alone overrated. They were certainly crap though

Agreed, it’s turned into a “crap 11”

Blair Sturrock was certainly overrated before he came, didnt he get described as the “architect”

[NorthLondonStag]

Paul Cannel

Still shout his name when I stub my toe,
or hit my thumb with a hammer.

Speaking of toes - Iffy Onuora. Thought he was going to be great, struggles with injury and for form and then went off and bagged loads of elsewhere.

[eggy]

Half the players being named in this thread were never rated in the first place, let alone overrated. They were certainly crap though

Agreed, it’s turned into a “crap 11”

Blair Sturrock was certainly overrated before he came, didnt he get described as the “architect”

Coronavirus will be over by the time we get through players hyped up by David Holdsworth.

[Sandy Pate Best Stag]

Duffy and Perry must be the most inept pairing who came with great expectations.

I think they got more stick from their own supporters than they did from opposition fans. Seem to remember them physically fighting over who was going to take a penalty in one match.

[arsene wengers coat]

Shane Bradley. 100k allegedly, Pfft. Righto.

[I am Spartacus]

Shane Bradley. 100k allegedly, Pfft. Righto.

Spot on

[lifestags]

Duffy and Perry must be the most inept pairing who came with great expectations.

I think they got more stick from their own supporters than they did from opposition fans. Seem to remember them physically fighting over who was going to take a penalty in one match.

Worksop away? Luke Medley and Rob Duffy that was, I always thought Perry was half decent tbh!

[The One]

Duffy and Perry must be the most inept pairing who came with great expectations.

I think they got more stick from their own supporters than they did from opposition fans. Seem to remember them physically fighting over who was going to take a penalty in one match.

.was that when we had to play at Ilkeston, because we were locked out

[Sneag]

Duffy and Perry must be the most inept pairing who came with great expectations.

I think they got more stick from their own supporters than they did from opposition fans. Seem to remember them physically fighting over who was going to take a penalty in one match.

.was that when we had to play at Ilkeston, because we were locked out

We both were. It was Worksop's home game.

[spainmick]

Roddy Collins was a top bloke though ..we often drank with him Friday nights in The Coopers

[Big yella]

Shane Bradley. 100k allegedly, Pfft. Righto.

Spot on

His best performance for us was when playing for THEM.