bobbystagsfan wrote:tibby wrote:MTFCMusings wrote:tibby wrote:tillydog123 wrote:Glad Mellis wants to be here as he is a league 1 player in reality and yes agree needs to put a lot more in next season and is an important player for us.
Unreal this place. What planet is Mellis a league 1 player? If he was, we would have gone up, automatically. He goes missing for large chunks of the game. The love in for him and the rest of the bottlers is bizarre. They are not good enough. We need to upgrade the midfield and the strikers or we are going nowhere. Tomlinson, not good enough. Mcdonald, not good enough. We need less ‘huffers and puffers’ and more quality players who can actually win us games.
Mellis provided many quality moments last year, you must have had your eyes shut. He is the most creative player currently on the books. He doesn't do it week in week out which is why he is playing in League Two.
If mellis is the most creative player on our books, that is exactly the problem, right there. Just because he is the best of a bad bunch doesnt mean he is a fantastic player.
Average rating from Martin on match reports since New years day - 6.5.
Not good enough
Take your rose tinted glasses off.
On a side note, if Hamiton is as good as everyone makes out and West Brom want him, he should have dragged us over the line. Simple as that. Too many players with big reputations that didnt perform for large parts of the season.
If we dont have an offensive clear out, I will put money on us not making play offs next season.
you'll be disappointed because Dempster said this job is not a rebuild. he said we have quality players at the club and is looking to add to that
Conker wrote:arsene wengers coat wrote:Is Mellis just verbal at the moment.
Won't shed a tear for Tyler going elsewhere, although I feel that he actually owes us a promotion for.his.stipid red card and penalty miss, he's lightweight and I won't mourn his loss or begrudge his return.
Incredible, you could argue Walker had the biggest contribution out of any of the players.
Anyway I imagine he’s not coming back here, because believe it or not he’s way to good for us.
arsene wengers coat wrote:Conker wrote:arsene wengers coat wrote:Is Mellis just verbal at the moment.
Won't shed a tear for Tyler going elsewhere, although I feel that he actually owes us a promotion for.his.stipid red card and penalty miss, he's lightweight and I won't mourn his loss or begrudge his return.
Incredible, you could argue Walker had the biggest contribution out of any of the players.
Anyway I imagine he’s not coming back here, because believe it or not he’s way to good for us.
He's fast but not powerful. Just a bit whispy.
tibby wrote:MTFCMusings wrote:tibby wrote:tillydog123 wrote:Glad Mellis wants to be here as he is a league 1 player in reality and yes agree needs to put a lot more in next season and is an important player for us.
Unreal this place. What planet is Mellis a league 1 player? If he was, we would have gone up, automatically. He goes missing for large chunks of the game. The love in for him and the rest of the bottlers is bizarre. They are not good enough. We need to upgrade the midfield and the strikers or we are going nowhere. Tomlinson, not good enough. Mcdonald, not good enough. We need less ‘huffers and puffers’ and more quality players who can actually win us games.
Mellis provided many quality moments last year, you must have had your eyes shut. He is the most creative player currently on the books. He doesn't do it week in week out which is why he is playing in League Two.
If mellis is the most creative player on our books, that is exactly the problem, right there. Just because he is the best of a bad bunch doesnt mean he is a fantastic player.
Average rating from Martin on match reports since New years day - 6.5.
Not good enough
Take your rose tinted glasses off.
On a side note, if Hamiton is as good as everyone makes out and West Brom want him, he should have dragged us over the line. Simple as that. Too many players with big reputations that didnt perform for large parts of the season.
If we dont have an offensive clear out, I will put money on us not making play offs next season.
tibby wrote:Am i right in thinking Mcdonald and Mellis have been here 2 seasons? What makes anyone think they will improve? They have been key parts of a team of failures.
There isnt many of our non-loanees that wouldn have handled the step up to league 2.
A trio of Tomlinson Mellis and Mcdonald in league 1? No chance
MTFCMusings wrote:tibby wrote:Am i right in thinking Mcdonald and Mellis have been here 2 seasons? What makes anyone think they will improve? They have been key parts of a team of failures.
There isnt many of our non-loanees that wouldn have handled the step up to league 2.
A trio of Tomlinson Mellis and Mcdonald in league 1? No chance
Also rubbish.
The whole defence.
Olejnik.
Bishop, Mellis, CJ
Would all have been fine. It’s League One not the Champions League.
tibby wrote:Am i right in thinking Mcdonald and Mellis have been here 2 seasons? What makes anyone think they will improve? They have been key parts of a team of failures.
There isnt many of our non-loanees that wouldn have handled the step up to league 2.
A trio of Tomlinson Mellis and Mcdonald in league 1? No chance
tibby wrote:Thats my point. We have Mcdonald who was a long term casualty and Tomlinson who seemingly wasn’t fit or is bad. Why? Was the budget not there, or simply wasted?
Grant was a lazy signing, as was the goalie.
It all seems poorly put together in hindsight. Bishop, oldest player im the side by some way, is the most reliable midfielder out of the whole lot of them. Speaks volumes.
Love to see 4-4-2 but Mellis would be further exposed. He doesnt seem comfortable getting up and down the field to me and seems to have very little fight.
arsene wengers coat wrote:Conker wrote:arsene wengers coat wrote:Is Mellis just verbal at the moment.
Won't shed a tear for Tyler going elsewhere, although I feel that he actually owes us a promotion for.his.stipid red card and penalty miss, he's lightweight and I won't mourn his loss or begrudge his return.
Vice President wrote:tibby wrote:Am i right in thinking Mcdonald and Mellis have been here 2 seasons? What makes anyone think they will improve? They have been key parts of a team of failures.
There isnt many of our non-loanees that wouldn have handled the step up to league 2.
A trio of Tomlinson Mellis and Mcdonald in league 1? No chance
I agree regarding Macca and Tomlinson.
Mellis is ok, but his stats for the season are not good and Grant is a better player. It is a shame that DF didn't play Grant for those last few games ... we might have got that all important goal that the likes of Macca & Mellis couldn't produce or contribute to.
tibby wrote:Grant certainly had more in his locker than the mentioned 3, just couldnt produce it consistently. Maybe a man management issue.
I think he will carve himself a good career in the game.
grufti wrote:This 'New signings' thread has nothing to do with new signings
Return to Stagsnet Main Discussion Forum
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 277 guests