kevin kents tasce wrote:No-one is saying that they should stop or criticising the efforts they put in.
I agree that on the whole Martin does a really good job.
Just pointing out that their description of the game sometimes offers little resemblance to what is actually happening. If the game is being listened to and not watched then this is a problem, especially when listeners pay for the service.
Stop over reacting to a bit of feedback that should be seen as an opportunity to improve the product.
Martin Shaw wrote:kevin kents tasce wrote:No-one is saying that they should stop or criticising the efforts they put in.
I agree that on the whole Martin does a really good job.
Just pointing out that their description of the game sometimes offers little resemblance to what is actually happening. If the game is being listened to and not watched then this is a problem, especially when listeners pay for the service.
Stop over reacting to a bit of feedback that should be seen as an opportunity to improve the product.
I think that's the most insulting comment that could be made to a commentator or reporter. The job is to relay to the listener what is going on and I do my best to do that faithfully. I've been doing match reports for a long time and I'd like to think they are generally respected. Of course not everyone is going to agree, that's obvious, because everyone has their own opinion. What goes in the report is essentially a repeat of what I say in commentary, just condensed down.
kevin kents tasce wrote:It certainly wasn't written as an insult Martin, but it is my opinion. Like I said on the other thread. It is clear that this is not a welcome point of discussion. You generally do a great job and I commend your commitment. I stand by my opinion, but I'll just leave this topic where it is.
yorkshire stag wrote:pmsl Stagsnet could fall out with themselves without outside help
& i thought i was argumentative lol
Tippy Tappy Football wrote:I don't think Yorkie is argumentative..........just very impatient...tick tock
georgefostersbeard wrote:yorkshire stag wrote:pmsl Stagsnet could fall out with themselves without outside help
& i thought i was argumentative lol
We all think you are argumentative
bellwhiff wrote:One person states a genuinely held opinion and the wolves circle.
Isn’t this place by definition about opinions?
If it is a genuinely held opinion then let them state it and defend it.
Return to Stagsnet Main Discussion Forum
Users browsing this forum: awalkinthepark, Beyond The Pale, Cleveland_Stag, Frankenstag, MTFCMusings, naanbread2, oldweststander, ST4GS, Stags Head Stags, steiner and 138 guests