Bros wrote:I wonder if he brought Logan back for the experience he has when we had the makeshift defence for a few games. Now the 3 Musketeers are back he can put Smith back in as he is more adventurous with his distribution and commanding the box
Vice President wrote:Smith is better than Logan.
I don't recall Smith doing anything wrong.
Logan makes me (and his defence) nervous - and he makes too many costly errors.
I can't understand why DF dropped Smith. If we persist with Logan for these crucial last games I think it will be very costly.
adamstag wrote:Vice President wrote:Smith is better than Logan.
I don't recall Smith doing anything wrong.
Logan makes me (and his defence) nervous - and he makes too many costly errors.
I can't understand why DF dropped Smith. If we persist with Logan for these crucial last games I think it will be very costly.
Rumour has it they’ve fallen out
pemill wrote:adamstag wrote:Vice President wrote:Smith is better than Logan.
I don't recall Smith doing anything wrong.
Logan makes me (and his defence) nervous - and he makes too many costly errors.
I can't understand why DF dropped Smith. If we persist with Logan for these crucial last games I think it will be very costly.
Rumour has it they’ve fallen out
So why doesn't he go back to Forest.
Just for the record Smith's kicking is woeful and he made a mistake at Port vale, there will be others too but forgotten about as his isn't on a naughty list, meaning every mistake Logan makes will be logged, analysed in detailed and talked about forever.
Tippy Tappy Football wrote:I will support either of them as they can both do a good job for us.
Jordan Smith P11 W6 D1 L4
Conrad Logan P10 W4 D5 L1
If Conrad leaves the Stags then it would not surprise me if Lincoln signed him. His kicking would suit them down to the ground.
James wrote:Tippy Tappy Football wrote:I will support either of them as they can both do a good job for us.
Jordan Smith P11 W6 D1 L4
Conrad Logan P10 W4 D5 L1
If Conrad leaves the Stags then it would not surprise me if Lincoln signed him. His kicking would suit them down to the ground.
How many of Jordan's games have been with the settled 3 of Sweeney, Pearce & Preston compared with Logan?
MTFCMusings wrote:James wrote:Tippy Tappy Football wrote:I will support either of them as they can both do a good job for us.
Jordan Smith P11 W6 D1 L4
Conrad Logan P10 W4 D5 L1
If Conrad leaves the Stags then it would not surprise me if Lincoln signed him. His kicking would suit them down to the ground.
How many of Jordan's games have been with the settled 3 of Sweeney, Pearce & Preston compared with Logan?
5 out of 11. 5 out of 10 for Logan (2 before Sweeney joined).
The stats are misleading anyway, as they don't show how the GK's actually contributed in those games.
Foresttownstag wrote:Smith will be back in goal tomorrow.
pemill wrote:MTFCMusings wrote:James wrote:Tippy Tappy Football wrote:I will support either of them as they can both do a good job for us.
Jordan Smith P11 W6 D1 L4
Conrad Logan P10 W4 D5 L1
If Conrad leaves the Stags then it would not surprise me if Lincoln signed him. His kicking would suit them down to the ground.
How many of Jordan's games have been with the settled 3 of Sweeney, Pearce & Preston compared with Logan?
5 out of 11. 5 out of 10 for Logan (2 before Sweeney joined).
The stats are misleading anyway, as they don't show how the GK's actually contributed in those games.
Oh Yes, the stats are misleading quote because they don't show what you want to see - classic. I guess if those stats were the other way round you'd be slating Logan on the basis we've lost 4 games while he's been in goal. Need a revamp of the stats to show only games where we have lost with CL in goal, that should suit the argument.
Here's a stat for you, we've only lost 6 in the league all season, 4 of those with Smith in goal
MTFCMusings wrote:pemill wrote:MTFCMusings wrote:James wrote:Tippy Tappy Football wrote:I will support either of them as they can both do a good job for us.
Jordan Smith P11 W6 D1 L4
Conrad Logan P10 W4 D5 L1
If Conrad leaves the Stags then it would not surprise me if Lincoln signed him. His kicking would suit them down to the ground.
How many of Jordan's games have been with the settled 3 of Sweeney, Pearce & Preston compared with Logan?
5 out of 11. 5 out of 10 for Logan (2 before Sweeney joined).
The stats are misleading anyway, as they don't show how the GK's actually contributed in those games.
Oh Yes, the stats are misleading quote because they don't show what you want to see - classic. I guess if those stats were the other way round you'd be slating Logan on the basis we've lost 4 games while he's been in goal. Need a revamp of the stats to show only games where we have lost with CL in goal, that should suit the argument.
Here's a stat for you, we've only lost 6 in the league all season, 4 of those with Smith in goal
What are you talking about Pemill? Add the points up, who has gained more? The stats who exactly what I want them to show, as do my eyes.
See also the rest of the thread, where not one person, including yourself, has picked Logan over Smith.
Return to Stagsnet Main Discussion Forum
Users browsing this forum: Newhall1, Nutty Stag and 137 guests