ParisStag wrote:Looked a penalty at the end. Preston had his arm out, pushing the striker away. Lucky.
bellwhiff wrote:Good goal.
Couple of missed chances again. Should be finishing them. When they click, some team is going to get a hiding
PS. Not a pen in a million years. Blatant dive
Marky Mark wrote:ParisStag wrote:Looked a penalty at the end. Preston had his arm out, pushing the striker away. Lucky.
Was thinking the same, wouldnt have been much argument if it had been given.
arsene wengers coat wrote:How did that 'best keeper in the league' not save that header. If Logan had let that in there would be uproar.
Reckon CJ and Tyler should both have scored.
adamstag wrote:Put it this way, had that not been given for us at home late on folk would have been going mental.
One of those 50/50 decisions - as tilly mentions our luck was in yesterday
Chander Lear wrote:If that was outside of the box then it would have been a free kick. soft or not. 100% peno.
A peno is a foul inside the box and it shouldn't be looked at differently to any other foul anywhere on the pitch
Analysis of the game post-match is now ridiculous. Looking for contact etc
Rob wrote:Chander Lear wrote:If that was outside of the box then it would have been a free kick. soft or not. 100% peno.
A peno is a foul inside the box and it shouldn't be looked at differently to any other foul anywhere on the pitch
Analysis of the game post-match is now ridiculous. Looking for contact etc
There is a difference, if you give a penalty you are almost certainly awarding a goal, if you are giving a free kick, you almost certainly aren't. Therefore, referee's have to be more certain before giving a penalty than a free kick outside the area. If this was not the case then you could award a penalty at every corner kick as there is always pushing, usually by defenders and strikers so how do you decide - unless it is blatant (Kane in the WC) then you just let them get on with it! I have seen this incident numerous times now and the referee got it correct, it is a contact sport Chander and both players were at it. I think you watch too much TV football
Chander Lear wrote:Rob wrote:Chander Lear wrote:If that was outside of the box then it would have been a free kick. soft or not. 100% peno.
A peno is a foul inside the box and it shouldn't be looked at differently to any other foul anywhere on the pitch
Analysis of the game post-match is now ridiculous. Looking for contact etc
There is a difference, if you give a penalty you are almost certainly awarding a goal, if you are giving a free kick, you almost certainly aren't. Therefore, referee's have to be more certain before giving a penalty than a free kick outside the area. If this was not the case then you could award a penalty at every corner kick as there is always pushing, usually by defenders and strikers so how do you decide - unless it is blatant (Kane in the WC) then you just let them get on with it! I have seen this incident numerous times now and the referee got it correct, it is a contact sport Chander and both players were at it. I think you watch too much TV football
Fair enough point. It still just gripes me .
Quite the opposite actually. I barely watch football on TV these days. Stags, England on TV occasionally Southampton. Other than that I'm not too fussed.
Chander Lear wrote:Rob wrote:Chander Lear wrote:If that was outside of the box then it would have been a free kick. soft or not. 100% peno.
A peno is a foul inside the box and it shouldn't be looked at differently to any other foul anywhere on the pitch
Analysis of the game post-match is now ridiculous. Looking for contact etc
There is a difference, if you give a penalty you are almost certainly awarding a goal, if you are giving a free kick, you almost certainly aren't. Therefore, referee's have to be more certain before giving a penalty than a free kick outside the area. If this was not the case then you could award a penalty at every corner kick as there is always pushing, usually by defenders and strikers so how do you decide - unless it is blatant (Kane in the WC) then you just let them get on with it! I have seen this incident numerous times now and the referee got it correct, it is a contact sport Chander and both players were at it. I think you watch too much TV football
Fair enough point. It still just gripes me .
Quite the opposite actually. I barely watch football on TV these days. Stags, England on TV occasionally Southampton. Other than that I'm not too fussed.
Return to Stagsnet Main Discussion Forum
Users browsing this forum: Bradders, MTFC Man, Tomwh and 241 guests