Conker wrote:He shows how evident it is Macca is a winger and not a CM.
Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
Sedgwick wrote:Offer 300-600K and Derby will snap your hand off... Hanson who has had more first team experience but shown his not good enough went to oxford for 180K
We were also close to signing Jayden Bogle at right back but hes done fantastically well to get a place in their first team.
Amberheart wrote:Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
My thoughts too excellent player & a big strong lad as well .
I am Spartacus wrote:Quick feet, footballing brain and fits in well with Ian ‘player of the season already’ Bishop. A welcome addition to the side. Another example of how we are moving, as a club, in the right direction. A young footballer who wants to play football and play it well. Not the mercenary ‘established’ stars that may not have necessarily done so well here in the last 18 months
Spent the second half that, regretfully, explaining to someone near me that he is not related to the blonde who bursts from the birthday cake in the film Under Seige.
Took a while for it to sink that Erica Eleniak does not have a brother that plays for Derby called Tim. Shame really as I think Paul Nylon could make a fortune organing birthday parties with ‘that’ cake.
Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
Conker wrote:Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
It's okay to make a quick judgement on a player/manager but not a bad one ey Rob?
Seriously though it's too early to say anything like that really, although he's clearly a natural CM unlike Macca who is more a winger but can do a job in the middle.
Rob wrote:Conker wrote:Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
It's okay to make a quick judgement on a player/manager but not a bad one ey Rob?
Seriously though it's too early to say anything like that really, although he's clearly a natural CM unlike Macca who is more a winger but can do a job in the middle.
Fair point, but I was only commenting on his performance last night, which was better than anything I have seen from Macca (who I do like by the way). To be honest, I think I would look half decent playing alongside Bishop, he needs wrapping up in cotton wool for he is utter class.
Conker wrote:Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
It's okay to make a quick judgement on a player/manager but not a bad one ey Rob?
Seriously though it's too early to say anything like that really, although he's clearly a natural CM unlike Macca who is more a winger but can do a job in the middle.
MTFCMusings wrote:Conker wrote:He shows how evident it is Macca is a winger and not a CM.
Macca's a good workhorse but needs someone along side him to do the creating.
Rob wrote:Conker wrote:Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
It's okay to make a quick judgement on a player/manager but not a bad one ey Rob?
Seriously though it's too early to say anything like that really, although he's clearly a natural CM unlike Macca who is more a winger but can do a job in the middle.
Fair point, but I was only commenting on his performance last night, which was better than anything I have seen from Macca (who I do like by the way). To be honest, I think I would look half decent playing alongside Bishop, he needs wrapping up in cotton wool for he is utter class.
Conker wrote:Rob wrote:Conker wrote:Rob wrote:I thought he was absolutely outstanding, effort, skill, creativity - the whole lot. In a different league to Macca for me.
It's okay to make a quick judgement on a player/manager but not a bad one ey Rob?
Seriously though it's too early to say anything like that really, although he's clearly a natural CM unlike Macca who is more a winger but can do a job in the middle.
Fair point, but I was only commenting on his performance last night, which was better than anything I have seen from Macca (who I do like by the way). To be honest, I think I would look half decent playing alongside Bishop, he needs wrapping up in cotton wool for he is utter class.
That we can agree on, Bishop is quality - not had that in the middle since Ben Whiteman.
stags4eva wrote:MTFCMusings wrote:Conker wrote:He shows how evident it is Macca is a winger and not a CM.
Macca's a good workhorse but needs someone along side him to do the creating.
He's not though he's just a headless chicken most of the time - another Jamie McGuire (our fans have idolised centre midfielders who can't pass for years for some reason)
When he's fit i'd try him at right wing back tell him to use all that energy getting up and down the wing - and he loves taking a throw in.
It's no suprise to me results/performances have instantly improved since he got injured.
Return to Stagsnet Main Discussion Forum
Users browsing this forum: Gruff, LincolnStag11, MTFC Man, Nutty Stag, robbingdog and 147 guests