grufti wrote:Regarding Diamond allowing Dennis in on 41 mins to get the shot in, Dennis nudged Diamond out of the way to prevent Diamond heading clear - should have been a foul.
could have been a foul. But would have been soft in my opinion.
kevin kents tasce wrote:Hemmings 6?
The rest of the report is very fair, but other than Benning i had Kane as the best player on the park
Hemmings wasn't involved in any of the big moments of the game at either end of the park. He did ok, some nice touches, but not more on this occasion in my opinion.
ParisStag wrote:Think you're a tad harsh on Atko and Macca. Both ran their socks off, chased lost balls and retrieved possession after plenty of hopeful clearances by Benning and Diamond went to the opposition in the first half. I thought Mal wasn't great first half apart from the cross to Rose, but was excellent second half. Agree with your ratings for Bennett and Logan though - both excellent.
Atkinson and MacDonald worked very hard in midfield. Both players always do. Atkinson was good in my opinion (hence 7). MacDonald is still not hitting the form I expect from him (hence just under 7).